Canibais e Reis

  • artigos comentários

21 de Maio, 2011

The questionable wisdom of a low-fat diet and cholesterol reduction

Autor: O Primitivo. Categoria: Dieta| Primitivos| Saúde

Soc Sci Med. 1994 Aug;39(3):433-47.

The questionable wisdom of a low-fat diet and cholesterol reduction.

Atrens DM.
Department of Psychology, University of Sydney, N.S.W., Australia.


The prevalent wisdom that a low-fat diet and cholesterol reduction are essential to good cardiovascular health is coming under increased scrutiny. An examination of the foundations of this view suggests that in many respects it was ill-conceived from the outset and, with the accumulation of new evidence, it is becoming progressively less tenable. Cross-sectional, longitudinal and cross-cultural investigations have variously suggested that the relationship between dietary fat intake and death from heart disease is positive, negative and random. These data are incompatible with the view that dietary fat intake has any causal role in cardiovascular health. Although hypercholesterolemia is associated with increased liability to death from heart disease, it is as frequently associated with increased overall life expectancy as with decreased life expectancy. These findings are incompatible with labelling hypercholesterolemia an overall health hazard. Moreover, it is questionable if the cardiovascular liability associated with hypercholesterolemia is either causal or reversible. The complex relationships between diet, serum cholesterol, atherosclerosis and mortality and their interactions with genetic and environmental factors suggest that the effects of simple dietary prescriptions are unlikely to be predictable, let alone beneficial. These cautions are borne out by numerous studies which have shown that multifactorial primary intervention to lower cholesterol levels is as likely to increase death from cardiovascular causes as to decrease it. Importantly, the only significant overall effect of cholesterol-lowering intervention that has ever been shown is increased mortality. The stress and helplessness associated with misapprehensions as to the dangers of dietary fat and the asceticism inherent in the war on cholesterol have considerable implications for health practices. Recent research in behavioral immunology suggests that stress and helplessness are likely to compromise immunity and promote ill-health.

Tags: cardiovascular, cholesterol, , , , myths

sem comentários a este artigo.

Formulário para comentário




Loading ... Loading ...

RSS Primal Wisdom (Don Matez)

  • The Case of the Missing Extinctions
  • Who Said Paleo Diet Had High Fat Percentages? Part 1
  • Out of Office
  • Venus Revisited, 2
  • Venus Revisited
  • Venus Figurines and Upper Paleolithic European Diets
  • Estimated macronutrient and fatty acid intakes from an East African Paleolithic diet: Part 1
  • Conventional Meat May Contain MAR Bacteria: What To Do About It
  • Meat vs Wheat: Tales From T Colin Campbell's China Study
  • Epistemology: Percepts, Concepts, and Conceptual Frameworks

RSS That Paleo Guy (Jamie Scott)

  • The failings of gross biochemistry
  • Routine Periodic Fasting Is Good for Your Health, and Your Heart
  • Feedback
  • What do nutritionists and dieticians study? Not evolution.
  • The Testosterone Report
  • Fatty Acids in Early Life
  • Sitting is killing you
  • Observations
  • Caffeine and Glucose Metabolism
  • You know it is winter when...

RSS Obesity Panacea (Saunders & Janiszewski)

  • This Week In Brief: May 15-21
  • Canadian Kids Do Not Have the Skills Needed to be Physically Active
  • Sitting is Killing You
  • The Science of Starvation: How long can humans survive without food or water?
  • Forks Vs Feet – Watch the Debate Live Here Starting at 11:55 EST on May 12
  • Exercise and Weight Loss – A Primer
  • 7 Myths About Physical Activity
  • Livechat tonight with Darya Pino at 9:30pm EST
  • Exercise vs Diet – A Live Debate (May 12 @ uOttawa)
  • Is “Wine and Milk” Better than “Wine and Cheese”?

RSS Heart Scan Blog (Dr. William Davis)

  • Scientists are freakin’ liars
  • Tell me your wheat elimination story and receive a copy of my new book, Wheat Belly
  • Real men don’t eat carbs
  • Why do the Japanese have less heart disease?
  • Niacin: What forms are safe?
  • What are "normal" triglycerides?
  • 1985: The Year of Whole Grains
  • Have some more
  • When MIGHT statins be helpful?
  • The New Track Your Plaque Guide now available

RSS Low-carb Forum

  • Coffee May Lower Risk of Prostate Cancer
  • Calories in / Calories out......or Hormones?
  • Dr. Charles Mobbs: Diabetic Kidney Damage Can Be Reversed With High-Fat, Low-Carb
  • Low Carb Causes Type 2?????
  • Plant Sterols may be Toxic to the Heart
  • Take-Home Messages From 2011 Nutrition & Metabolism Society Symposium In Baltimore
  • Conjectures
  • GMO kills cattle
  • 0-6 to 0-3 ratio
  • GMO studies raising questions

RSS Fat New World (Jekyll)

  • Seminário "Inflamação e Dor Crónica": a minha overview
  • O "Peso Pesado" vs "The Biggest Loser": semana 3
  • Comentário à notícia da RTP1: "Especialistas dizem que a dieta de Atkins pode aumentar risco de doenças cardiovasculares"
  • "Who Made Me Fat?"
  • O "Peso Pesado" e os "amarelos ao ataque": chamam a isto uma refeição equilibrada?
  • O "Peso Pesado" e a proteína do brócolo
  • O poder do chocolate
  • O "Peso Pesado" vs "The Biggest Loser": semana 2
  • Revisitando o passado: uma caloria não é uma mera caloria (Kekwick e Pawan, 1956)
  • Comentário ao artigo "Perder gordura sem ganhar músculo"

RSS Musculação-pt (Colossus)

  • A técnica correcta do supino
  • O efeito combinado da whey, creatina e glicose
  • O resveratrol do vinho tinto pode ajudar na luta contra a obesidade
  • Programa “Grease the Groove” para força
  • Osteocalcina para aumento da testosterona e tratamento da infertilidade
  • Engordamos com o clima frio?
  • Variações do supino
  • 9 Passos para uma saúde perfeita – 9: Pratique o prazer
  • A carne apodrece no seu cólon? Não. O que apodrece? Leguminosas, cereais e vegetais!
  • O que você come após o exercício é importante.

  • Dieta Perfeita Anti-IBS, mitos alimentares expostos, provas científicas absolutas, e explicações cósmicas e bíblicas como bónus
  • Who Made Me Fat?, documentário da BBC
  • Para quem ainda não se apercebeu, rede social Twitter está a bombar a 200 km/h!
  • Very Cool Infographics
  • Hans Rosling, Gapminder and the joy of stats: “Statistics is now the sexiest subject on the planet”
  • Mais rendimento per capita e mais civilização significam necessariamente mais saúde e longevidade?
  • The Great Fat Debate - Is There Validity in the Age Old Dietary Guidance?
  • The Diet Solution Program, pela nutricionista Isabel de Los Rios
  • The questionable wisdom of a low-fat diet and cholesterol reduction
  • Attitudes to food and the role of food in life in the U.S.A., Japan, Flemish Belgium and France: possible implications for the diet-health debate
  • O Primitivo: Concordo que os nutricionistas raramente dizem coisas acertadas, e tenho feito uns tantos comentários sobre isso. Sobre a entrevista em questão, ach
  • Helder Correia: Pena que em Portugal os nutricionistas que vao 'a televisao so' dizem disparates. Como e' o caso desta senhora que aconselha comer pao ao lanche para
  • Sérgio: Acho que o meu comentário à cerca de ineficácia dos programas de treino aeróbico, e não da actividade física quotidiana, foi mal interpretado. Q

Canibais e Reis

"As populações da Idade da Pedra tinham vidas mais saudáveis do que a maior parte do povo que surgiu imediatamente depois delas. Quanto a facilidades, como a boa alimentação, os divertimentos e os prazeres estéticos, os primitivos caçadores e recolectores de plantas gozavam de luxos que só os mais ricos dos nossos dias podem gozar" - Marvin Harris (1927-2001).

Dietas primitivas e tradicionais


Hipótese Lipídica


Vitamina D

Podcasts (áudio)